Alien movies make the usual error!
by Kyeli on December 26th, 2008 @ 8:57 am in
Usual Error Project
The other day, I was thinking about how nearly every alien movie I’ve seen involves the aliens coming to Earth and utterly destroying everything ever or making us all into mindless slaves forever until some clever humans figure out how to kill them or make them go away.
I hate this plot with a firey burning passion. If and when aliens come to Earth, they’re far more likely to do something completely alien to us because they’re aliens! Either that, or they’ll pity us or make peace with us or something. So I got to thinking, wtf? Why is Alien Rampage such a common plot device?
Then it hit me – it’s because of the usual error!
No, seriously! Throughout history, when Mother Culture Humans would find a less advanced civilization, they would utterly destroy it or make it submit to them. Native Americans could tell you all about that. So could the Druids, the Aztecs, the Mayans, Australian aborigines… and the list, sadly, goes on and on.
It’s such a common behavior, in fact, that many people think it’s “human nature”. (It’s not, but that’s a different post.) Since it’s that common, we make the usual error and assume other species would act the same as we do. And then that makes us afraid, because that means we are the less advanced civilization sitting pretty, ripe for the conquering. And thus, a horrible, overused plot device is born.
I think the other part of this pathetic plot is our egotism, which makes people think that only a vastly advanced alien race could be our downfall, but I’m sure you can figure out what I think of that.
Anyway, let’s hope those aliens won’t be so… human. What I really hope is that those who think it’s human nature to be pointlessly cruel or senselessly violent will eventually die off and the rest of us can greet the alien visitors with peaceful apologies for our past behavior and otherwise open arms.
Hah. Barring that, maybe we can at least befriend the aliens and they’ll share awesome technology with us before they make us all their slaves. (;
- Related posts:
- The Usual Error book review roundup, part 2
- The Usual Error audiobook!
- We made the usual error!
- The Usual Error meets Seth Godin
- Revolutionary Tuesday: An evil genius zots the dude with three memes
Have you read our book, The Usual Error? It teaches you how to solve communication issues with compassion and understanding, how to get rid of needless conflict from your life, how to make your relationships smoother, and how to generally be happier. Also, the illustrations are super cool. (:You can buy it on Amazon or read it for free online. |
4 Comments!
#2 Posted by
Sheila on December 28th, 2008 3:01 pm | link
Well, think about it, there’s no real way to write a truly ‘alien’ point of view, because all stories about aliens are written by human beings.
The same thing happens, in a sense, when we write about ’superior’ beings–we write about the things we want to become and wish we could be. This is not entirely a bad thing, unless you wind up doing that weird self-loathing thing whereby you feel ‘inferior’ in your mere ‘humanity’ to creatures that are products of human imagination.
#3 Posted by
Adam on December 30th, 2008 3:53 pm | link
At this point, who’d want to get to know us? Human kind is afraid of every new thing it learns. I think that’s somewhat evolutionary, protecting the species and all, but it sure doesn’t make you have much self esteem as a species. The alien movies are an example of that. “It’s weird. Shoot it!” Like your other post, we can’t just be fierce, we have to be bad.
Of course the problem Sheila mentions is true, too. How can we write about aliens when we’re the ones doing the writing? And then you’d have to sell it to a big movie studio. From there it’s all downhill…
Some days our humanity makes us very small. But whadda you gonna do?
#4 Posted by
Julia on January 8th, 2009 7:49 pm | link
It’s not a movie, but for a somewhat different perspective on aliens, try reading James White’s Sector General novels.














#1 Posted by
Green on December 26th, 2008 9:00 pm | link
It’s very interesting (and a cool point that you made) that our great fear of aliens is based upon the assumption that they will be just like us.